Annuities

Annuities for Retirement Income

Principal protection, tax-deferred growth, and income you cannot outlive, shopped across top-rated carriers in all 27 states I am licensed in.

See my 3 income matches → Free retirement income quiz · about 3 minutes · no obligation
The short version
  • An annuity is a contract with an insurance company that protects money, grows it tax deferred, and can turn it into income you cannot outlive.
  • The main types for retirees: MYGAs (a set rate for a set number of years), fixed indexed annuities (index linked growth with a floor), and income annuities (a lump sum turned into a paycheck).
  • The tradeoffs are real: surrender periods, limited upside on indexed products and fees on optional riders. Read them before you sign.
  • They tend to fit people near or in retirement who want protection and income. They rarely fit young savers who need growth and liquidity.
  • I shop the carriers I am appointed with and focus on fixed and fixed indexed annuities. If one does not fit you, I will say so.

What an annuity actually is

An annuity is a contract with an insurance company. You hand them a sum of money, and in return they protect that principal and pay you growth or income later, backed by the claims paying ability of the insurer. That is the whole idea. For most families near retirement it does two jobs at once: it keeps your money safe from a market crash, and it can turn a lump sum into a paycheck you cannot outlive.

Every annuity has two possible phases. In the accumulation phase your money grows tax deferred. In the income phase the contract pays you, either for a set number of years or for the rest of your life. Some annuities do only one of those jobs. Some do both.

The main types of annuities

MYGA (fixed)A rate set for a fixed number of years, often 3 to 10. Predictable, simple, and often compared to a CD.
Fixed indexedGrowth linked to an index like the S&P 500 with a floor of zero. You share in part of the gains and do not lose principal to market drops.
Immediate incomeAlso called a SPIA. You trade a lump sum for income that starts within a year, often for life.
Deferred incomeYou buy income today that starts years from now, which usually means a bigger check when it begins.

Variable annuities are a different animal. Their value moves with investment subaccounts, they can lose money in down markets, they often carry higher fees, and they are securities sold by registered representatives. This page focuses on fixed and fixed indexed annuities, which are insurance products. For a full side by side, read fixed vs indexed vs variable annuities.

MYGAs: the CD alternative

A multi year guaranteed annuity, or MYGA, is the simplest annuity there is. You deposit a lump sum, the carrier sets an interest rate for a chosen number of years, and your money grows at that rate, tax deferred, for the whole term. At the end you can renew, move it to another annuity, take it as income or withdraw it.

Fixed indexed annuities

Your growth is linked to a market index like the S&P 500, but with a floor of zero. In a good year you share in part of the gain. In a bad year you do not lose principal to the market. The tradeoff is honest: caps and participation rates limit how much of the upside you keep, so you will not get the full market return. What you get instead is growth potential without the market losses that scare retirees the most.

A hypothetical example Assume an 8% cap and a 0% floor. If the index rises 12%, the annuity is credited 8%. If it falls 15%, it is credited 0% and your credited value does not drop from the market. These numbers are made up to show the mechanics. Real caps and participation rates are set by each carrier and can change at renewal.

Many fixed indexed annuities offer an optional income rider for an annual fee. It creates an income value used only to calculate a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal amount. That income value is not cash you can walk away with, which is one of the most misunderstood details in the whole industry. Ask how the rider fee is charged and what the actual payout percentage would be at your age.

How income you cannot outlive actually works

This is the part almost nobody explains in plain words. An insurance company pools the longevity risk of thousands of people. Some live longer than average, some shorter. Because they spread that risk across everyone, they can promise you a monthly income for the rest of your life, no matter how long you live, in exchange for a lump sum today or an income rider you add to the contract. It is the closest thing to a private pension a retiree can still buy.

You choose how payments work. Life only pays the most per month but stops at death. Joint life keeps paying as long as either spouse is alive. Period certain or cash refund options guarantee your heirs receive something if you die early, in exchange for a smaller check.

A common approach is to cover your essential bills, housing, food and insurance, with guaranteed income from Social Security, any pension and an annuity, and leave the rest of your savings invested for growth and flexibility.

Annuity pros and cons

Pros
  • Principal protection from market losses on fixed and fixed indexed annuities
  • Tax deferred growth
  • Income you cannot outlive
  • No IRS annual contribution limit on non qualified money
  • Beneficiaries can receive the remaining value, often outside probate
Cons
  • Surrender charges if you need the money early
  • Capped upside on indexed annuities
  • Rider fees on optional income features
  • Gains are taxed as ordinary income, not capital gains
  • Withdrawals before 59 and a half can trigger a 10% IRS penalty

So, are annuities a good investment? An annuity is less an investment and more a protection and income tool. For someone near or in retirement who wants principal protection and income they cannot outlive, it can be a very good fit. For a younger person with decades to invest for maximum growth, it usually is not.

How annuities are taxed

Your own situation matters, so confirm the details with a tax professional before you move money.

Funding an annuity from a 401k or IRA

Many retirees fund an annuity with money from an old 401k or IRA. Done right, it is a tax free transfer. Done wrong, it can create a tax bill. The key points:

For the bigger picture, read what to do with your 401k when you retire.

Who an annuity fits, and who it does not

An annuity tends to fit someone who is near or in retirement, wants income they cannot outlive, and does not want a crash to wreck the savings they spent decades building. It is a protection tool, not a lottery ticket.

It is usually the wrong tool if you are young with decades to invest, if you need every dollar liquid, or if your only goal is maximum growth. I will tell you when it does not fit. Putting someone in the wrong product is how agents lose families for good, and that is not the business I am building.

What to watch for before you sign

  1. The surrender schedule. How many years, the charge in each year, and the free withdrawal allowance.
  2. Caps and participation rates on indexed annuities, the guaranteed minimums, and how often they can change.
  3. Bonus annuities. An up front bonus often comes with a longer surrender period or lower caps. Look at the whole contract.
  4. Income rider fees and the difference between the income value and the cash you can actually withdraw.
  5. Replacing an existing annuity. Moving one annuity into another can restart surrender charges. Make sure the new contract clearly beats the old one.
  6. The insurer's financial strength. The guarantees depend on the carrier's ability to pay claims.

Most states also give you a free look period after delivery, often 10 to 30 days depending on the state and your age, to review the contract and cancel for a refund.

How I help

1

A retirement call

Phone or video. What you have saved, when you plan to retire, what your guaranteed income already covers and where the gap is.

2

Side by side options

I compare MYGAs, fixed indexed and income annuities across the carriers I am appointed with, with the surrender terms and fees laid out plainly.

3

A clean transfer

If an annuity fits, we handle the paperwork and a direct transfer so your money moves without avoidable taxes.

If an annuity is not right for you, I will say so. You can verify my license or read more about me. Spanish speakers can start at anualidades.

Common questions about annuities

Are annuities a good investment for retirement?

An annuity is less an investment and more a protection and income tool. For someone near or in retirement who wants principal protection and income they cannot outlive, it can be a very good fit. For a younger person with decades to invest for maximum growth, it usually is not.

What is a MYGA?

A multi year guaranteed annuity locks a fixed interest rate for a set number of years, often 3 to 10. Growth is tax deferred, and most allow a limited free withdrawal each year with surrender charges on more than that.

Can you lose money in an annuity?

Fixed and fixed indexed annuities protect your principal from market losses. You can still lose money by surrendering early, through rider fees, or to taxes and penalties on early withdrawals. Variable annuities can lose value with the market.

What happens to my annuity when I die?

It depends on the contract and payout choice. During accumulation, the remaining value usually goes to your beneficiaries. With life only income, payments stop at death, while joint life, period certain and cash refund options can continue to pay your heirs.

How much income would an annuity pay me?

It depends on your age, the amount, interest rates, whether income covers one or two lives and any guarantee for heirs. Because rates change, the only accurate number is a current quote on your own details.

Can I move my 401k into an annuity?

Yes, typically through a direct rollover to an IRA annuity, which avoids withholding and taxes when done correctly. Compare what you would give up in your plan before you move it.

Are annuities better than CDs?

They do different things. CDs are bank deposits with FDIC insurance and taxable interest each year. MYGAs are insurance products with tax deferred growth backed by the insurer. Compare rates, terms and liquidity at the time you buy.

For educational purposes only. Not financial, tax or investment advice. Consult a licensed professional. Examples are hypothetical. Guarantees are backed by the claims paying ability of the issuing insurer. Rates, caps, fees, surrender charges and features vary by carrier and state and can change. Withdrawals are subject to income tax and may be subject to a 10% IRS penalty before age 59 and a half. Products offered by licensed agents only.